Every November, a bird that took days to plan is set down on a dish that is plainly too small for it. Slices hang over the edge, the juices head for the tablecloth, and the garnish never stood a chance.

The fix is simple. A good platter comes down to three things you can check on any product page before you buy: how long it is, how the rim is shaped, and how much heat it can take.

Golden roasted turkey garnished with oranges and rosemary
Photo by Prchi Palwe on Unsplash

Start with the tape measure

Size is where most platters fail. BestReviews' buying guide notes that most serving platters are bigger than a 12-inch dinner plate, and that a true turkey platter should be at least 16 inches wide. Southern Living's editors set the same floor: at least 16 inches, with room for the bird and its garnishes.

Julie Robbins of the dinnerware retailer Replacements, Ltd. has seen the mistake often. In an article distributed by Brandpoint, she said people try to put a large turkey on a 12-inch platter, and that it is simply too small to work.

Bigger is not automatically better, though. BestReviews advises against a platter so small the food hangs over the rim, and against one so large it looks as if some of the food is already gone. If your bird is modest and your platter is not, Robbins suggests filling the space with vegetables arranged around it.

For a sense of scale, Ina Garten's make-ahead roast turkey, published by Williams Sonoma, calls for a 12-by-16-inch platter for a 12- to 14-pound bird. Made In lists its Turkey Platter at 19.2 inches long and 14.9 inches wide, and just over 6 pounds before any food goes on it. Size brings weight, a point BestReviews makes too, so measure the cabinet shelf and be honest about who will be carrying it to the table.

Look for a rim that holds the juices

A flat board is fine for cheese. A roast needs somewhere for the juices to go. BestReviews calls this the well, the lowest part of the platter where juices and sauces collect, and counts it as an asset for serving roasts.

Makers describe the same idea in different words. Made In says its platter has a flat center and slightly sloped walls meant to contain a turkey's juices. Le Creuset describes its stoneware Serving Platter as having ridged edges that slope upward to hold food in, with two wide handles cut into the ends for a steady grip on roasts or poultry.

As for looks, you have more freedom than the holiday aisle suggests. BestReviews names the oval as the most common and versatile shape and white as the most versatile color. Robbins adds that a turkey platter does not need a turkey on it. Patterns run from florals to scenic views, and the right one is the one that suits your table.

Read the heat rating before you fall in love

Here is where a platter can earn its keep. Garten's method is to carve the turkey ahead, arrange it over a quarter-inch layer of gravy on the platter, and put the whole thing in the oven for 15 to 30 minutes, until the meat is very hot. Her recipe adds a pointed warning to "make sure it's ovenproof!"

Not every platter is, so read the care section. Le Creuset lists its stoneware platter as oven-safe up to 500 F and broiler-safe when it sits at least 2 1/2 inches below the heating element, but never for the stovetop. Made In lists its platter as dishwasher-, microwave- and freezer-safe. If the oven is not on a maker's list, do not assume it.

Melamine, which BestReviews suggests for anyone who wants something attractive and light, has its own rule. The FDA says food may be served on melamine tableware, but food and drinks should not be heated on it in the microwave. Heat the food in a dish labeled microwave-safe, then transfer it.

However handsome the platter, it is not a warming tray. USDA says hot food should be kept at 140 F or warmer, and perishable food should not sit at room temperature for more than two hours.

One last piece of advice comes from BestReviews' cooking expert, Andrea Boudewijn: settle the menu first, then go through the cabinets to see which platters and bowls the meal calls for. Shop for the gap, not the whole shelf.

Shop the post

This section contains affiliate links. A purchase made through them may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. See the Policies page for details.

Is there a platter in your family that only comes out once a year? Tell its story in the comments.

Sources

Thank you for reading! -Edie O.

Comment

Did you love this? Let us know!

Name
Email
Message
Thanks for contributing to our community! Your comment will appear shortly.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Follow Along on Instagram @Edieoeats